• Home
  • Blog
  • Online Courses
  • Forum
  • Login/ Register
    • Profile
    • Shopping Cart
    • Checkout
  • Contact
Cross Cultural LearningCross Cultural Learning
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Online Courses
  • Forum
  • Login/ Register
    • Profile
    • Shopping Cart
    • Checkout
  • Contact

Commentaries

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Commentaries
  • Review, India-Pakistan: Coming to Terms, By Amit Ranjan

Review, India-Pakistan: Coming to Terms, By Amit Ranjan

  • Posted by M R
  • Date April 3, 2011
  • Comments 0 comment

India-Pakistan: Coming to Terms. Ashutosh Misra. Palgrave Macmillan Publications: New York, 2010. 288 pages. ISBN: 978-0-230-61937-1.

Lots of books, research articles and editorials focusing upon the need for good relations between India and Pakistan have been written, but the two South Asian, nuclear-armed neighbors are still adamantly hostile to each other. The root cause of their conflict is their claim and counter claim to the entire region of Jammu and Kashmir. They have even fought three full wars, one limited war and a series of proxy wars but are yet to resolve this issue. No formal or informal talks between India and Pakistan can be concluded without raising the subject of ‘Kashmir’. Thinking rationally, one feels that the two countries, for the time being, should put this issue into political cold storage and focus on other bilateral conflicts between them. In the event they resolve those issues they could apply the same mechanism and methods to address Kashmir. Ashutosh Misra’s work is a step in
that direction. Unlike others, he has tried to cautiously avoid the Kashmir issue and focuses upon the negotiations and dialogue process over resolved and nonresolved conflicts between India and Pakistan.

Leaving aside a detailed analysis of the Kashmir question, the author has talked about the Indus Water Treaty (IWT) of 1960, the Siachin dispute, the Sir Creek dispute, the Rann of Kutch and the Tulbul/ Wular barrage. On the basis of his research, Misra has described the conflict between the two as an “enduring conflict,” a term used by many, including T.V. Paul, to describe India-Pakistan dispute. But despite such disagreements, on certain issues both countries follow the defensive neo-realist dictum that even traditional rivals cooperate if they find that cooperation is in their mutual interest. The Indus Water Treaty of 1960 is one
such example.

The author has taken into account the theoretical aspects of negotiations, and talks about how negotiations proceed, about ripeness of the dispute, pre-negotiations, negotiation and agreement. India and Pakistan have followed this process but the
relationship is so delicate and complex that one untoward incident negates all the hard work done by an individual or group of individuals. Mr. Vajpayee’s and Nawaz Sharif’s intentions were mowed down by the Kargil episode, then Dr. Manmohan Singh’s and Pervez Musharraf’s step forward faltered due to Mumbai carnage. Once these types of incidents take place the relationship goes back to zero and for any further political engagement one has to start from scratch. There is an absolute lack of continuity in bilateral dialogue, which is a must for resolution of any ensuing conflict. . . .

(For the full version, please visit Pakistaniaat: A Journal of Pakistan Studies)

Tag:India, Indus Water Treaty, Kashmir, Manmohan Singh, Nawaz Sharif, Pakistan, T.V. Paul, Yousaf Raza Gillani

  • Share:
M R
M R
Originally from Pakistan, Dr. Masood Ashraf Raja is an Associate Professor of Postcolonial Literature and Theory and the editor of Pakistaniaat: A Journal of Pakistan Studies. Raja tweets @masoodraja

Previous post

A Shameful Foreign Policy: Deploying Pakistani Troops In Bahrain
April 3, 2011

Next post

Pakistan Forum: What are we All About?
April 3, 2011

You may also like

Pakistan Government’s Phone Tax Policy and its Implications for Travellers
25 August, 2019

Introduction According to the most recent Phone Tax Policy of the PTI government in Pakistan, all those entering Pakistan, both citizens and foreigners, must register their phones and pay a …

Getting Approved for Media Net in Two Days
11 June, 2019

Lately, I have been trying to monetize some of my websites and blogs. As I was looking for the best Adsense alternative, I was pointed to Media Net as a …

Driving While Brown: Fast Food Chains as Safe Places?
21 May, 2019

I have been thinking about writing on this topic for quite some time now, but never really got around to doing so. Maybe, I had to get over my implicit …

Leave A Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Download Free Pdf

balck background with books

Course Collections

  • Free Courses
  • Literary Studies
  • Free Courses
  • Literary Studies

Education WordPress Theme by ThimPress. Powered by WordPress.